Press releases
Israel: Elor Azaria conviction is 'glimmer of hope' over unlawful military killings
‘The verdict … offers a glimmer of hope that soldiers who commit unlawful killings may no longer go unpunished’ - Philip Luther
The conviction of an Israeli soldier who shot dead a Palestinian man involved in a knife attack in Hebron last year as he lay wounded on the ground offers a small glimmer of hope amid general impunity for unlawful killings in the Occupied Palestinian Territories, said Amnesty International today.
The soldier, Elor Azaria, was today found guilty of the manslaughter of Abed al-Fatah al-Sharif, one of two Palestinians believed to have been involved in the stabbing of an Israeli soldier on 24 March in Hebron, after a military court ruled that his actions violated the Israeli army’s rules of engagement.
Video evidence which emerged of the incident showed Azaria appearing to shoot the injured man with no apparent justification, and the court ruled that the only reason for the shooting was his wish to take revenge for the previous knife attack. For a soldier to carry out the deliberate killing of someone who had been captured and posed no imminent threat to life would amount to an extrajudicial execution and is a crime under international law.
Azaria’s claims that he had acted in self-defence fearing the wounded man wore an explosive vest were firmly rejected by the court.
A spike in violence in the West Bank since October 2015 has seen a rise in unlawful killings - including stabbing and other attacks on Israeli soldiers, police and civilians by Palestinians and apparent extrajudicial executions by Israeli forces in the Occupied Palestinian Territories. Over the past year at least 16 Israelis have been killed during attacks by Palestinians and at least 110 Palestinians killed by Israeli forces. Previous Israeli investigations into such violations have fallen far short of international standards. In several cases Israeli forces were not held accountable despite strong evidence that a crime had taken place.
Amnesty International’s Middle East and North Africa Research and Advocacy Director Philip Luther said:
“The verdict is a small step in the right direction and offers a glimmer of hope that soldiers who commit unlawful killings may no longer go unpunished.“Today’s conviction of a member of the Israeli forces is a rare occurrence in a country with a long record of using excessive and unwarranted force, and where soldiers who may have committed crimes under international law very seldom face prosecution.“Sadly, this case is just the tip of the iceberg. Time and again we have witnessed cases where Israeli forces appear to have carried out unlawful killings, displaying an appalling disregard for human life.“The authorities’ repeated failure to hold anyone accountable for flagrant violations has fostered a culture in which unlawful killings have become acceptable. To end this bitter cycle of unlawful killings it is crucial that those responsible for violations are held accountable for their actions.”
In a memorandum sent to the Israeli authorities last September, Amnesty highlighted at least 20 cases of apparently unlawful killings of Palestinians by Israeli forces. In at least 15 of these cases, those killed were deliberately shot dead despite posing no imminent threat to life.