Destroying Islamic State may push Lebanon to the brink

With momentum building over the US and its international partners carrying out airstrikes on Islamic State targets in Syria as well Iraq, almost nothing has been said about what this might mean in terms of population flows and new refugees.

In just a few short weeks of its terrifying scorched earth campaign in and round Mosul in Iraq, Islamic State uprooted a colossal 600,000 people. Inhabitants of villages like Kocho and Qiniyeh were either massacred or managed to flee to the inhospitable terrain of Mount Sinjar. In a terrible twist of fate, many of these traumatised people have exchanged certain death in Iraq for the deep uncertainties and mortal dangers of Syria.

Donate to support our work for Syrian refugees

Attacking Islamic State will mean more refugees

A new wave of attacks on Islamic State’s roving bands of killers will surely displace thousands more local residents. It’s hard to see how aerial assaults on militants - or even the prospect of mass attacks - can have any other effect. What plans has John R Allen, the retired US general charged with overseeing the anti-Islamic State drive, made for those caught in this new pincer movement?

I raise these matters having recently returned from Lebanon where I witnessed the plight of some of the 1.4 million Syrian refugees now living in the country. Consider that number for a moment. Lebanon had a pre-Syrian conflict population of around five million people. It’s seen a gargantuan influx of more than a quarter of its entire resident population, equivalent to something like 16 million refugees pitching up in the UK in the space of three years. And it isn’t stopping; Lebanon is still receiving 9,000 refugees a week from Syria.

Lebanon is already creaking at the seams

The numbers are off the scale and Lebanon is beginning to feel the strain. Despite the incredible hospitality and kindness of thousands of Lebanese people - some hosting distant relatives from across the Syrian border, many simply helping struggling strangers in their midst - the country is frankly creaking at the seams.

The head of the UN refugee agency in Lebanon, Ninette Kelly, told me that hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees in Lebanon are living in informal settlements, and even in garages and shops. I visited a refugee settlement in the Bekaa Valley, a two-hour drive from Beirut. Here hundreds of people are huddled under plastic sheeting strung across wooden struts (these are not even tents), many living on the bare earth. They are all but exposed to the elements, contending with freezing winters and searingly hot summers, and there are no kitchens and the few toilets are rudimentary. 

Healthcare emergency

Healthcare is virtually non-existent. I met a mother who fears her five-month-old boy may be deaf and suffering from a serious eye complaint, but the mother is unable to afford the treatment he undoubtedly needs. Another woman was caring for her mother who has suffered three strokes and her young daughter who has epilepsy - again, the treatment they need is unavailable and unaffordable. This second mother also fears for the fate of two of her brothers who are languishing in Bashar al-Assad’s prisons - they will almost certainly have suffered tortured and she’s in anguish at the thought that they’ll be killed.

Existence itself is hard but so is co-existence. In Bekaa there have been disputes between refugees and the local Lebanese community over access to water. Is this surprising? Lebanon is small, not especially wealthy and is already hosting the largest population of Syrian refugees of any country in the world. No-one knows when the conflict in Syria is going to end and in some quarters patience is running out.

This humanitarian crisis is bigger than Lebanon

Well over a year ago voices in the Lebanese government were saying the country had already “exceeded its ability to absorb” refugees, however desperate or deserving. Recently the atmosphere has become even more fraught after Islamic State beheaded two captured Lebanese soldiers. People say they’ve “woken up in a different world” after the beheadings, with anti-Syrian sentiments hardening and posters saying 'No Syrian refugees here' appearing on the streets. 

'Don’t tell us to keep our borders open while you close yours'
Lebanese government adviser

Syria’s is the world biggest humanitarian crisis and Lebanon and Syria’s other neighbours can’t manage this on their own. Around the world, despite the politicians’ promises, the response has been woeful. EU countries have taken less the 1% of Syria’s refugees, the UK a grand total of 75 people as of today.

As I left Lebanon a government adviser said to me “Don’t tell us to keep our borders open while you close yours”. It’s a remark that ought to be reverberating around Downing Street as the generals explain to David Cameron how they’re going to 'destroy' Syria’s Islamic State fighters.

This post was originally published on the Independent as Cameron and Obama may want to ‘destroy’ Isis, but what will they do about the growing number of refugees fleeing Iraq and Syria?

About Amnesty UK Blogs
Our blogs are written by Amnesty International staff, volunteers and other interested individuals, to encourage debate around human rights issues. They do not necessarily represent the views of Amnesty International.
View latest posts
1 comment

"Attacking Islamic State will mean more refugees" "It’s hard to see how aerial assaults on militants - or even the prospect of mass attacks - can have any other effect." well, at Kobane, the victory over IS achieved owing to US air strikes means that refugees are now beginning to return home. The 2014 Amnesty Report criticised the West for not doing enough to prevent the rise of IS. They can't do right in your eyes! Why not praise the US for a change?

The EU countries are democracies with Christian roots. Their electorates don't want them to admit hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees, with their very different culture. Instead ask them to do more to help the refugees in situ, in Turkey and Lebanon. Why not ask other Muslim countries to accept refugees?

Why are you so critical of the West and so uncritical of everyone else?

GH 3 years ago