UK: Domestic Abuse Bill risks failing migrant women
Government’s draft Domestic Abuse Bill falls short on protecting victims from perpetrators using immigration status as a ‘weapon to abuse’
‘The Bill barely tinkers at the edges of what is necessary to ensure migrant women are treated fairly’ – Kate Allen
Responding to the first draft of the UK Government’s Domestic Violence and Abuse Bill which was published earlier today, the Step Up Migrant Women coalition are warning that current proposals will fail to offer migrant women the protections they need.
Step Up Migrant Women (SUMW) - a coalition of more than 30 organisations, including the Latin American Women’s Rights Service (LAWRS), Southall Black Sisters, Amnesty International UK, Sisters For Change and End Violence Against Women Coalition - welcomes the Government’s commitment to tackle domestic abuse and violence and put survivors at the heart of its plans. However, SUMW is urging the government to ensure equal protection for migrant, refugee and BAME women survivors of domestic abuse who often slip through the gaps because of their particular experiences of violence.
Lucila Granada, Director of the Latin American Women’s Rights Service, said:
"The draft Bill offers little hope for migrant victims to access safety and support. This is particularly alarming, as the Bill itself recognises the ‘significant vulnerability’ of migrant victims who fear deportation as a result of coming forward.
“Every day we support women who are unable to trust that the police and the law will prioritise their lives and their safety simply because they are migrants. Deterring migrant women from reporting crimes gives impunity to perpetrators. We need a Bill that doesn't leave migrant women behind. We need safe reporting pathways, appropriate support, and a fair chance for migrant women to be able to break free from violence"
Kate Allen, Director of Amnesty UK, said:
“Whilst in some ways this Bill is ambitious, many of the protections it provides will remain out of reach for some of society’s most vulnerable women.
“Migrant women in abusive relationships are currently trapped and further victimised by their immigration status - excluded from financial support which often makes them reliant on their abuser and threatened with deportation should they seek support from the police.
“In its current form, the Bill barely tinkers at the edges of what is necessary to ensure migrant women are treated fairly.
“To truly be ground-breaking, the Bill must ensure all women can access housing and welfare support and report abuse without fear of immigration enforcement. Otherwise perpetrators will continue to use the immigration status of their victims as a weapon to control and abuse their victims.”
Andrea Simon, Public Affairs Manager at the End Violence Against Women Coalition, said:
“The Government recognises that they must do more to protect domestic abuse victims with no recourse to public funds, but proposals announced today do not address or reverse the hostile environment policies created by successive immigration bills, which create barriers to women seeking help and support and can be weaponised by abusers.
“A truly victim-centred Bill would recognise that all women who’ve experienced domestic violence should have access to protection and justice regardless of their immigration status. This is currently not the case, because only some women can access the limited safety net offered by the government in the Destitution and Domestic Violence Concession. This shames us as a society – when we clearly put immigration enforcement over women’s and children’s lives.”
What the Bill says about migrant and BAME survivors
Under human rights law, the Government has a duty to protect every woman in the UK from violence, irrelevant of immigration status. However, whilst the Bill recognises the need to overcome barriers to reporting for women with insecure immigration status, it offers little more than current provisions aimed at addressing the problem.
Guidance is already in place for police forces to support victims, but in reality the police often share data with the Home Office and domestic violence victims are treated as suspects by immigration enforcement. The Bill introduces nothing on a statutory footing to prevent this from happening.
Instead of ensuring migrant women can access vital support services such as refuges, the Government suggests some victims of domestic abuse “may be best served by returning to their country of origin and, where it is available, to the support of their family and friends”.
The draft Bill includes the provision of £300,000 funding for BAME organisations that are supporting survivors of abuse. Whilst it is welcome that the Government recognises the need to support BAME organisations, £300,000 will go little way to support a sector that is hugely underfunded.
The Bill must offer full protection for migrant women
The SUMW Coalition believes that the Domestic Abuse Bill must:
- offer a system of full confidentiality, protection and support for all migrant women who report their abuse, regardless of their immigration status. This policy must apply to all statutory services, including the police and GPs;
- make specialist organisations led by and for migrant and black and minority ethnic women – which have had their services decimated by funding cuts – a central part of tackling domestic abuse and violence;
- recognise the gender inequality underlying domestic abuse and the disproportionate impact on women and girls;
- ensure refuge provision becomes a statutory obligation backed by national ring-fenced funding;
- ensure all migrant women at risk of experiencing abuse have access to public funds and routes to regularise their immigration status independent of their perpetrator.