Indonesia: New report exposes rough justice for Aceh's conflict victims
Tens of thousands of victims and family members are still waiting for the Indonesian authorities to provide them with truth, justice and full reparation almost eight years after the end to the devastating Aceh conflict, Amnesty International said in a new report released today.
The report, Time to Face the Past (PDF), documents the failure of local and central authorities to establish the truth of what happened during the years of violence which left between 10,000 and 30,000 people dead, many of them civilians. A large number of those who had their lives torn apart by the conflict are still suffering immensely.
An Aceh victims’ representative told Amnesty International:
“[We] want to know why until now the government has not acknowledged that we suffered human rights abuses.
“We are still fighting, not against the government, but for the government to remember what happened to us. They do not have the right to forget.”
Isabelle Arradon, Amnesty International’s Deputy Asia Pacific Director, added:
“The Indonesian government’s failure to provide genuine truth, justice and reparation for victims and their families is causing immense suffering for people in Aceh today.
“Family members still do not know what has happened to disappeared loved ones and are struggling to get by, while those responsible walk free. The situation is breeding resentment that could sow the seeds of a future return to violence.
“The failure to prosecute those responsible is having grave consequences on the rule of law today. There is currently no vetting mechanism in the security forces to identify those accused of rights violations and to ensure they are not placed in a position where they can simply carry on past practices.
“This is true across Indonesia, where we are continuing to document serious human rights violations by security forces.
“By addressing the situation in Aceh, the Indonesian authorities could not only heal open wounds but also help to strengthen the rule of law and secure the peace process for the long-term.
”It would also send a strong signal to other victims of human rights abuses and their families in Indonesia, who are waiting for measures of truth, justice and reparation to address crimes committed in other situations.”
The Aceh conflict between the armed pro-independence movement Free Aceh Movement (Gerakan Aceh Merdeka, GAM) and the Indonesian government dated back to 1976, and peaked during military operations from 1989 until a peace deal was signed in 2005.
It took a devastating toll on the population in Aceh, a region on the northern part of Indonesia’s Sumatra Island.
Amnesty International and other human rights groups have documented a range of crimes committed by members of the security forces and their auxiliaries against the civilian population, including unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture.
Human rights abuses by GAM included hostage taking and the targeted killings of those suspected of ties to the government.
Many of these human rights abuses constitute crimes under international law, including possible crimes against humanity and war crimes. Under international law, Indonesia has an obligation to investigate these crimes, and where sufficient evidence exists, to prosecute suspects in accordance with international fair trial standards.
Furthermore, the 2005 peace agreement called for the establishment of both a Human Rights Court and a Truth and Reconciliation Commission for Aceh – neither of which exist today. Hardly any of those responsible for serious human rights abuses have been brought to justice, while attempts to provide reparation to victims have been inadequate.
Although there have been limited attempts by the Indonesia government and the National Human Rights Commission to investigate what happened in Aceh, the results have not been made available to the public.
Attempts to establish a truth commission at the national level have also failed. The Constitutional Court in 2006 struck down a deeply flawed law attempting to establish such a commission, because it provided that victims could only receive reparation if those suspected of the abuses had been granted an amnesty.
Parliament is due to take up the debate on a national truth commission again before 2014, but it is unclear if there is political will to establish one.
Meanwhile, victims and family members in Aceh are left without information about what happened during the conflict – including the fate of hundreds of “disappeared” persons who have yet to be accounted for.
As time passes, there is a risk that valuable information is being lost, making the establishment of an effective truth commission even more urgent.
The failure to establish the truth has contributed to a culture of impunity for the serious rights abuses committed during the conflict – not a single new case has been prosecuted since the 2005 peace agreement.
At the same time, a climate of fear still pervades in Aceh, with some victims’ representatives telling Amnesty International that they have received threats for their work on impunity for past crimes.
Efforts by the authorities to provide reparation to victims of the Aceh conflict have been patchy and inadequate.
The steps taken so far have mostly involved financial compensation, and have been aimed at the Acehnese population at large instead of individual victims of human rights abuses.
There has yet to be a comprehensive reparation programme that, on top of financial compensation, includes other measures such as rehabilitation, counselling for victims and commemoration programmes.
Some groups, like the large number of women who were subjected to sexual violence during the conflict, have been unable to access the existing programmes.
Download Time to Face the Past (PDF)