Egypt: Disastrous bloodshed must lead to urgent impartial investigation
‘There seems to be little doubt the security forces have been acting with blatant disregard for human life’ - Philip Luther
There must be a full and impartial investigation into the violent dispersal of sit-in protests in Cairo this week, where security forces used unwarranted lethal force and broke promises to allow the wounded to exit safely, Amnesty International said today on the basis of its research on the ground (PDF). Unprecedented levels of violence have left more than 600 dead around Egypt. The Ministry of Interior reported 43 fatal casualties among security forces. The death toll is expected to climb further as bodies are transferred to official hospitals and morgues. Amnesty is calling for UN experts - especially the Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions - to be given access to the country to investigate the circumstances of the violence and the pattern of excessive and unwarranted lethal force used by the Egyptian authorities since the “25 January Revolution”. Given the Egyptian authorities’ poor track record in holding members of the security forces accountable for using excessive and unwarranted lethal force against protesters in the past two-and-half years, Amnesty is concerned about the ability of the country’s Public Prosecution to conduct full, impartial and independent investigations. Amnesty also called on the Egyptian authorities to take immediate measures to improve security for Christians and other minorities amid an alarming rise in sectarian violence against Coptic Christians - seemingly in retaliation for their alleged support of the decision to oust Mohamed Morsi - including attacks on churches, businesses and homes in several governorates. The organisation has documented previous instances where the security forces have failed to protect Coptic Christian communities from such attacks. Amnesty International Middle East and North Africa Director Philip Luther said: “Based on the initial testimonies and other evidence we’ve gathered, there seems to be little doubt the security forces have been acting with blatant disregard for human life, and full investigations that are both impartial and independent are urgently needed. “While some protesters used violence, the authorities’ response was grossly disproportionate, seemingly not differentiating between violent and non-violent protesters. Bystanders were also caught-up in the violence. “Security forces resorted to lethal force when it was not strictly necessary to protect lives or prevent serious injury - this is a clear violation of international law and standards. Previous promises to use graduated force when dispersing the sit-ins and provide ample warning and safe exits were quickly broken.” Amnesty researchers have visited numerous hospitals and field hospitals in Cairo, as well as the city’s Zeinhum morgue and a mosque temporarily housing dozens of the dead, documenting scores of deaths, and gathering eyewitness reports from medical staff who described how many of the injured and dead had sustained bullet wounds to the upper body. “There were dozens of dead bodies and hundreds of injured people. They mostly sustained live ammunition wounds to the upper part of the body,” a doctor told Amnesty. A medical student described how Rabaa al-Adawiya hospital had to be evacuated after security forces entered the building amid heavy tear gas fire, and its first floor was set alight: “The security forces were attacking the hospital. The doctors ordered us to close the curtains and windows to avoid the tear gas. I saw snipers on the roofs of buildings near the hospital, they were dressed in black. Then another doctor told us that the security forces got into the first floor. … . One security officer hit me with the rifle-butt on my back and pushed me towards the stairs. I got out of the hospital. The security forces then told us to take the bodies and patients. The first floor was on fire.” Other eyewitnesses reported that the heavy gunfire outside the hospital prevented the safe exit of the wounded, and led to the death of a hospital security guard. A nurse at a field hospital at the Rabaa al-Adawiya sit-in told Amnesty how men in black uniforms threatened her at gunpoint: “There was a gun pointing at me through the window. There were three men, two in black uniforms and one in civilian dress. The civilian screamed at me telling me to open the door, and asking if we had weapons inside … I pleaded with them that there were only injured and dead inside.” Members of the armed forces denied Amnesty access to the Ta’min al-Sihi Hospital, which reportedly received 52 corpses of those killed in the clashes, including at least one woman. It also dealt with more than 200 injuries – at least half of which required the injured to be hospitalized for treatment. Meanwhile workers at Cairo’s Zeinhum morgue told Amnesty that by 10am on Thursday 108 autopsies had been carried out, and the facility was overflowing with corpses. Yesterday Amnesty researchers visited the Iman Mosque, which was converted into a makeshift morgue after family members brought in relatives killed in the Rabaa al-Adawiya sit-in, as well as some of those evacuated from Rabaa al-Adawiya hospital. At the time of the visit, there were 98 dead bodies inside, among them eight charred corpses - it is unknown whether they were burnt alive or after dying. Lists with names of 265 people had been hung on the mosque’s walls. Volunteers said that two more unidentified bodies had been brought in. Egypt’s Minister of Interior has justified the security forces’ conduct, claiming that protesters used violence, and that 43 members of the security forces, including 18 officers, have been killed across the country, with more than 200 injured. He claimed that the security forces provided warnings, and only used teargas until fired upon by pro-Morsi protesters. Particularly following the dispersals of the sit-ins, some Morsi supporters did use violence, including firearms, and launched attacks on the Giza Governorate building, police stations and security personnel. Police stations in Waraq and Kerdassa were attacked, with police officers captured, killed and beaten. In several instances, members of the security forces were captured and beaten, and one grieving relative told Amnesty that her cousin, a police officer, was decapitated on 14 August in Giza. Protesters at Rabaa al-Adawiya told Amnesty that they used rocks and Molotov cocktails and set police vehicles alight in an attempt to prevent the dispersal.
- Read our full briefing (PDF)