China: Woman buried alive as dash for development sees new wave of violent forced evictions
A wave of violent forced evictions, which has led to a number of deaths, is spreading across China as local authorities seek to offset huge debts by seizing and then selling off land in suspect deals with property developers, a new report by Amnesty International revealed today.
In the new 85-page report, Standing Their Ground (pdf), Amnesty highlights how forced evictions – a longstanding cause of discontent within China – have soared in the past two years in order to clear the way for luxury developments.
Local officials continue to sanction or turn a blind eye to the harassment of residents by developers using ruthless tactics to force people out of their homes and sell their rights to land-use.
Of 40 forced evictions that Amnesty International examined in detail as part of the research, nine culminated in the deaths of people protesting or resisting eviction.
In one case a 70-year-old woman, Wang Cuiyan, was buried alive by an excavator on 3 March 2010 when a crew of about 30 to 40 workers came to demolish her house in Wuhan city, Hubei Province.
Any individual who speaks up against the authorities also risks harassment. In Shandong province, authorities sent Li Hongwei, a victim of forced eviction, to 21 months in a Re-education Through Labour camp for delivering two protest speeches.
Meanwhile, a woman was beaten and forced to undergo sterilisation on 17 May 2011 after she had petitioned the authorities in Jiangxi province about her eviction. Other residents that accompanied her were beaten. Amnesty International considers forced sterilisation to be an act of torture.
With no access to justice some have turned to violence or even self-immolation as a last resort. Amnesty International collected reports of 41 cases of self-immolation from 2009 to 2011 alone due to forced evictions. That compares to fewer than ten cases reported in the entire previous decade.
Nicola Duckworth, Senior Director of Research at Amnesty International, said:
“The Chinese authorities must immediately halt all forced evictions. There needs to be an end to the political incentives, tax gains and career advancements that encourage local officials to continue with such illegal practices.”
The problem stems from huge borrowing by local government from state banks to pay for stimulus projects. To cover the debt the local authorities have turned to land sales to cover the payments.
China’s ruling Communist Party continues to promote local officials who deliver economic growth, regardless as to how it is achieved. Land re-development, at whatever cost – whether for new roads, factories or residential complexes – is seen as the most direct path to visible results. And it is this, the new report concludes, that has resulted in deaths, beatings, harassment and imprisonment of residents who have been forced from their homes across the country in both rural and urban areas.
Proper consultation or notice as required under international law as well as adequate alternative housing are seldom given and any compensation falls far short of the true market value.
Residents come under concerted campaigns including the cutting off of essential services like water and heating. Civil servants who oppose land deals often face reprisals.
Local governments and property developers frequently hire thugs wielding steel rods and knives to rough up residents. Housing rights activists, lawyers and academics in China confirmed Amnesty International’s finding that the police hardly ever investigate such crimes.
One violent example occurred on 18 April 2011 when a few hundred men entered Lichang village in Jiangsu Province and attacked farmers to force them off their land. About 20 Women's rights's rightss rights's rights's rights's rights from the village were dragged away and beaten.
On 21 June 2011, police in Wenchang city, Sichuan province even took custody of a 20-month old baby and refused to return him until his mother signed an eviction order.
The lack of independence in Chinese courts means those that seek to challenge an eviction or seek redress have little hope of gaining justice. Lawyers are also reluctant to take on such clients for fear of the repercussions.
Ni Yulan began providing legal aid to victims of forced evictions in 2001 and became a victim of this practice herself 7 years later. She was first detained in 2002 after filming a demolition. Since then she has been frequently detained and harassed. During one period of detention she was beaten so severely she has been unable to walk without crutches. In 2008, just before the Beijing Olympics, she was forcibly evicted from her own home. For defending her home and protesting against police malpractice she was given a two-year sentence. Upon her release in April 2010 she and her husband were homeless. She is now once again in prison, detained as part of 2011’s crackdown on dissent by the authorities.
Forced evictions remain one of the greatest issues of popular discontent within China. Premier Wen Jiabao has acknowledged the gravity of the situation and there has been some progress towards protecting people against forced evictions in line with international law and standards.
For the first time, new regulations adopted in 2011 state that compensation for homeowners must not be lower than market value and outlawed the use of violence.
However, these laws and regulations still fall far short of the required standards and apply only to city dwellers.
Rural communities remain vulnerable to forced evictions, particularly those close to urban areas. With urbanisation happening so quickly around them, and compensation based on the agricultural value rather than the true market value, farmers are often priced out of the communities they have lived in their whole lives.
Another major weakness in the latest regulations is that they only provide protections for owners of land, overlooking the rights of tenants.
Forced evictions – the removal against their will of individuals, families or communities from the homes or the land they occupy without access to legal or other protections – are banned under international law.
Amnesty International conducted research for this report between February 2010 and
January 2012 and examined 40 cases in detail. This included interviews with victims of forced eviction, lawyers and housing rights activists from across mainland China. Interviews were also conducted with international scholars and other authorities on Chinese land and housing rights and international housing rights advocates.
The report also draws on extensive Chinese and international academic research, studies by a Chinese human rights organisation and published accounts in both Chinese and international media.
Amnesty International is calling on the authorities to immediately halt all forced evictions and ensure adequate safeguards are put in place in line with international law, including:
- Implement effective measures to ensure the entire population a degree of security of tenure that would protect them from forced evictions and other threats and harassment.
- Ensure that nobody is rendered homeless as a result of a forced eviction and all persons who cannot provide for themselves are given adequate alternative housing.
- Ensure that all victims of forced evictions have access to independent and impartial adjudication of their complaints and to an effective remedy.
- Ensure housing rights activists and lawyers are able to carry out their important and legitimate work free from fear
- Punish and prosecute those who use violence during the eviction process.