Bahrain: dismissal of appeal in activists case denounced as 'outrageous'
‘The Bahraini authorities are not on the path of reform but seem rather driven by vindictiveness’ - Hassiba Hadj Sahraoui
Today’s decision by Bahrain’s appeal court to uphold sentences against 13 opposition activists and prisoners of conscience has been condemned as outrageous by Amnesty International, which is calling on the authorities to ensure that the ruling is overturned and the activists immediately and unconditionally released.
Earlier today the High Criminal Court of Appeal in Bahrain upheld convictions and sentences for 13 men who were convicted last year before military courts on charges related to anti-government protests. Amnesty sent a trial observer to Bahrain who was present in court.
The 13, who include prominent activist Abdulhadi Al-Khawaja and opposition political activist Ebrahim Sharif, were originally sentenced by a military court in June 2011 to between two years and life in prison on charges including “setting up terror groups to topple the royal regime and change the constitution”. All maintain their innocence.
Farida Ismail, Sharif’s wife, said: “I was expecting this outcome as it is clear to us the government is not ready to be held accountable - its procedures continue as before. There is not enough pressure from abroad. What happens next will depend on which steps are taken by the international community and what states do in the next Universal Periodic Review session. As for our government, it is clear it is not ready for justice.”
The convictions and sentences of the 13 were originally upheld before a military court of appeal in September 2011. But on 30 April this year Bahrain’s Court of Cassation ordered their appeal be held before a civilian court, a process which began on 22 May and ended with today’s verdict - announced in a session that lasted only three minutes.
Amnesty International Middle East and North Africa Deputy Director Hassiba Hadj Sahraoui said:
“Today’s court decision is another blow to justice and it shows once more that the Bahraini authorities are not on the path of reform but seem rather driven by vindictiveness.
“Today’s verdict further engulfs Bahrain in injustice. Instead of upholding the sentences, ranging from five years to life in prison, the Bahraini authorities must quash the convictions for the 13 men who are imprisoned solely for peacefully exercising their human rights and release them immediately and unconditionally.
“Bahrain cannot get a free pass at the UN Human Rights Council and we urge states to tell the Bahraini authorities that today’s verdict crosses a red line and that they can no longer be considered credible partners.”
Despite the Bahraini’s government attempt to portray itself as on the path to reform, Amnesty says that little has been done on the ground to ensure accountability and true justice for victims of human rights abuses. Violations are ongoing and prisoners of conscience remain behind bars.
Amnesty also repeated its call to the authorities to order an immediate and independent investigation into some of the allegations made by the 13 defendants during previous court hearings that they have been tortured and suffered other ill-treatment - including sexual assault - while in detention in order to coerce “confessions” from them. Fourteen opposition activists were originally arrested between 17 March and 9 April 2011 after taking part in pro-reform protests in Manama. One of the men was later released. Many have alleged they were tortured during their first few days of detention when they were being interrogated by officers from the National Security Agency (NSA).
None of the 13 was allowed to see their lawyers during the interrogations. Some saw their lawyers during questioning by the military prosecutor ahead of the trial in 2011, while others were only allowed to see lawyers during the first court hearing in May 2011, which was also the first time any of the activists had seen their families since their arrest. Some charges against three of the defendants were dropped on 4 September.
Bahrain’s human rights record will be under scrutiny during the next Universal Periodic Review (UPR) before the Human Rights Council in mid-September, when the Gulf state will have to confirm which recommendations made by its peers it accepts. During the previous UPR session in June, 176 recommendations were presented to Bahrain, including key proposals that, if accepted, would signal commitment towards ensuring accountability.
Fourteen opposition activists were originally arrested, namely: Hassan Mshaima’, Abdelwahab Hussain, Abdulhadi Al-Khawaja, Dr Abdel-Jalil al-Singace, Mohammad Habib al-Miqdad, Abdel-Jalil al-Miqdad, Sa’eed Mirza al-Nuri, Mohammad Hassan Jawwad, Mohammad Ali Ridha Isma’il, Abdullah al-Mahroos, Abdul-Hadi Abdullah Hassan al-Mukhodher, Ebrahim Sharif, Salah Abdullah Hubail al-Khawaja. Al-Hur Yousef al-Somaikh has since been released as he had served his sentence after the Court of Cassation reduced it to six months in prison.
Other prisoners of conscience currently held in Bahrain include:
Nabeel Rajab, the President of the Bahrain Centre for Human Rights and Director of the Gulf Centre for Human Rights, who is serving a three-year prison sentence for calling for and participating in “illegal gatherings”. An appeal on this case is due to start on 10 September.
Mahdi ‘Issa Mahdi Abu Dheeb, the former president of the Bahrain Teacher’s Association, is serving a ten-year prison term imposed by a military court for using his position "to call for a strike by teachers, halting the educational process and inciting hatred of the regime", among other charges. There is no evidence proving that he used or advocated violence.