Australia's Nauru camp is 'human rights catastrophe with no end in sight'
Posted: 23 November 2012
Amnesty International has found a toxic mix of uncertainty, unlawful detention and inhumane conditions creating an increasingly volatile situation on Nauru, with the Australian Government spectacularly failing in its duty of care to asylum seekers.
Following a three-day inspection of the facility, Amnesty researchers found the facility totally inappropriate and ill-equipped, with 387 men cramped into five rows of leaking tents, suffering from physical and mental ailments - creating a climate of anguish as the repressively hot monsoon season begins.
Amnesty International’s Refugee Expert Dr Graham Thom, said:
“The situation on Nauru is unacceptable. The unlawful and arbitrary detention of these men in such destitute conditions is cruel, inhuman and degrading.
“The climate of uncertainty was debilitating with no information being provided to asylum seekers and clear evidence that this temporary holding facility has been erected in haste, with no consideration for the individuals languishing in such squalid conditions.
“On our final day speaking with the detainees, the downpour was torrential, the site was flooded, tents were leaking – one man’s shoes drifted away as the current ran through the tent. We were also prevented from photographing conditions despite assurances we would be able to do so.
“The news that five years could be the wait time for these men under the government’s ‘no advantage’ policy added insult to injury, with one man attempting to take his life on Wednesday night.”
Amnesty is calling on the Australian Government to immediately cease transfers to Nauru as the human rights organisation can see no purpose in holding asylum seekers on Nauru other than penalising them for seeking asylum.
Dr Graham Thom, said:
“For those already on Nauru, processing must start immediately, with freedom of movement allowed as envisaged by the Expert Panel so that at least some uncertainty is addressed and these men can live some semblance of a normal life.
“Offshore processing on Nauru and Manus Island will only serve to break vulnerable people in these ill-conceived limbo camps, who have fled unimaginable circumstances.”
Amnesty is also gravely concerned by the Coalition’s proposal to cut the increased humanitarian intake. The human rights organisation believes the only way of preventing asylum seekers from taking dangerous boat journeys to Australia is to provide them with viable alternatives. This includes building the capacity of Australia’s neighbouring countries to respect refugee rights as well as Australia increasing its humanitarian intake.
Once again Amnesty reiterates that seeking asylum is a fundamental legal and human right. Any attempt to portray their arrival as illegal is grossly misleading.